The Western Australia Court of Appeal urged that prison sentences not be reduced due to prison conditions
The Western Australia Court of Appeal has ruled that judges generally should not reduce sentences for convicts due to overcrowding and inadequate conditions in the state’s prisons. The decision was handed down by a panel of the state’s three highest-ranking judges, according to ABC News Australia.
Previously, some judges had considered prison conditions as a mitigating factor. In particular, last month, when sentencing Michael Vrchovsek to 16 years in prison for attempted murder, the court took into account the chronic shortage of space and severe, inhumane overcrowding at Gakia Prison.
The Court of Appeal noted that some judges had occasionally taken into account the well-known problems at Gakiia Prison or expressed sympathy for inmates who had been held in lockdown conditions for a long time. At the same time, the panel concluded that such circumstances cannot be properly taken into account when determining the sentence.
For more breaking news, follow the UA.News Telegram channel.
The court emphasized that this decision does not imply approval of the current conditions of detention. Earlier this year, Western Australia’s prison oversight body stated that inmates in three facilities had been subjected to cruel, inhuman, or degrading treatment. According to the agency’s assessment, the government has allowed the prison system to become “virtually dysfunctional.”
Jamie Wolvish, a law professor at the University of Western Australia, stated that the ruling clarifies future practice and does not invalidate previous sentences. According to him, an individual sentence reduction is possible if overcrowding has particularly severe consequences for a specific person due to their age, disability, or mental health issues.
State Attorney General Tony Buti, who recently also took charge of correctional services, said he had requested an urgent briefing on overcrowding. He said this year’s budget allocates more than $300 million in new funding for the justice system and corrections, specifically to create additional beds and opportunities for meaningful activities for inmates.
